The Live-Action HTTYD Spoiled Me…

Now I’m hesitant to revisit the original animated version.

As an early birthday present, I was treated to an IMAX showing of the new How to Train Your Dragon, the one with real people and real animated dragons. And while I may have been the oldest person in the audience, I was not the only baby boomer (i.e., senior). After all, I have a knitting project bag that says

I will never be too old for Toothless.

The movie is a nearly scene-for-scene remake, but I can’t complain. After all, it’s hard to improve on perfection. Some lines were changed, a few added, a few more deleted. So, after a very long hiatus, here is a new Sunday Seven.

Seven thoughts on How to Train Your Dragon (2025)

1. John Powell’s score is little changed. And where it is, it’s actually better than the original. (And here I thought you couldn’t improve on perfection!) If you don’t know my feelings about the score, my mantra since 2011 has been

John Powell was robbed (of an Oscar)!

2. Toothless is even more adorable! Again, I guess you can improve on perfection. (Hiccup is also pretty adorable.)

3. The other teens resent Hiccup to a greater degree. They see Hiccup not only as inept, but also feel he gets special treatment because he’s the chief’s son. It emphasizes how much of an outcast Hiccup really is and puts greater pressure on him to succeed.

Dragon training--Ruffnut, Astrid, Tuffnut, Fishlegs, and Gobber

Dragon training: Ruffnut, Astrid, Tuffnut, Fishlegs, and Gobber

4. There seems to be a bit of a friendship between Astrid and Tuffnut. It’s more obvious from Tuffnut’s perspective… because who wouldn’t want to be friends with Astrid?

5. The Monstrous Nightmare is downright frightening. I actually had a jump-scare when he attacked Stoic from the flames. (Re: pronoun: we know this dragon is male because that’s how he’s identified in all the follow-on HTTYD properties.)

The Monstrous Nightmare

6. The scene with the Terrible Terrors following Hiccup’s and Toothless’s “test flight” is deleted. It’s a key scene because it establishes that dragons are “not so fireproof on the inside.” This is the technique that ultimately defeated the Red Death, so I feel it should have been included.

David Tennant and the the 10th Doctor Who

7. Spitelout (Snotlout’s father) is not played by David Tennant. Tennant, who you may remember as Doctor Who‘s beloved 10th Doctor, narrated all the How to Train Your Dragon audiobooks and voiced Spitelout in the original movie (all 2-3 lines). He also appeared in all four seasons of the HTTYD series spinoffs, Riders of Berk, Defenders of Berk, and both seasons of Race to the Edge. Nonetheless, Peter Serafinowicz does an admirable job of portraying Spitelout’s disappointed, disapproving “tough love.”

Snotlout and his father Spitelour from HTTYD's animated series.

Will I return to the theater to see How to Train Your Dragon in RealD 3D? Yes, I will.

All photos ©2025 Universal/DreamWorks via IMDB.

3 responses to “The Live-Action HTTYD Spoiled Me…”

  1. Natalie J. Damschroder Avatar
    Natalie J. Damschroder

    Every time I saw the preview for this I was thinking of you and wondering what you thought! 🙂 So glad to read your take and that it lived up to your fandom. 🙂

    1. Gailann Avatar
      Gailann

      Wow, you didn’t give up on me!

      The movie’s getting mixed reviews. Most center around the fact that Astrid is a person of color. (Sounds like latent racism to me. The director said she was the best actor who tried out for the role. (I.e., not DEI)

      I’ve been binging on YouTube reactions to the original. It’s loads of fun and a great time-waster. 😉

      P.s. I’m looking for a more readable blog style, but it’s been tough going.

      1. Natalie J. Damschroder Avatar
        Natalie J. Damschroder

        Of course I didn’t!Yeah, I read some stuff about that. They do that with everything. It’s disgusting.FWIW, I like everything you do here, in whatever style you do it. 🙂

Talk to me!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.